Sediment Control Issues you See on Construction Sites (and How to Address them the Right Way)
At any construction site after a large overnight downpour, the script is pretty much the same. Brown water runs down the driveway, across the footpath, and into the stormwater pit at the front of the site. A silt fence rests flat in the mud, having apparently given up the ghost in the middle of the night. A site supervisor, a coffee in hand, proclaims he “only just” looked at the place the previous Friday.
Control of sediment isn’t complex but its implementation often is. What we most commonly see are issues not because of poor products or difficult terrain but because people didn’t take the time to install it properly, to check the product, or to stay on top of it because their guys’ interest is gone after the framework is put up.
In this document, I will identify the most common problems, explain why they happen and the solutions to the fixes.
Sediment Fences Were Fitted As An Afterthought
Sediment fences installation is an important element of sediment control. When properly installed, a silt fence will be very effective.
The most common mistake is not trenching the fabric into the ground. Sometimes laborers simply unroll the fabric, pound in a few star pickets, staple the fabric in place, and call it a day. As a result, the bottom of the fabric set on the ground. When the first heavy rain occurs, water runs underneath the fabric, washing away the topsoil. The end result is the fabric end up being just a fancy looking feature rather than a real control.
Other common missteps include:
- Fences that run straight down rather than across the contour.
- Insufficiently close post-spacing causing sagging and collapse of the fabric under load
- Garment that is ripped, taped or has entire pieces of fabric missing
- Fences that are not continuous, and water can run around the ends
The correct action is to trench the fabric. Dig a trench approximately 150 to 200mm deep, and bury the fabric bottom into it, then fill it back up and pack it in. The fence needs to be placed along the contour to let the water pond up behind it and give it time to settle the sediment out. The ends need to be turned uphill so that water doesn’t flow around the end and through the entire fence. The posts need to be placed close enough so that the fence can take the weight of the wet soil. Remove any broken sections and replace it, rather than patching it up with tape.
Absence of Maintenance
No matter how well the sediment control is designed, it will never be effective without the proper maintenance.
The sediment fences collect debris over time and the sediment can eventually topple the fence once the sediment has accumulated. Gully pit filters become plugged and water just goes around them. The sandbags can split, or be moved by delivery trucks or moved out of the way for concrete trucks and left in their new locations.
Why this was to happen is because the job is not clear who will do the maintenance. The apprentice knows that the supervisor is watching, the supervisor knows that the civil contractor is working, and the civil contractor knows that someone else will do the maintenance. In this way the control measures go to hell.
The answer is to identify a person to be responsible for maintenance. Make sure you have a name for that person. A short walk-around of the pond every week and after every rain event. Ridding of any sediment build-up before it reaches onethird of the height of the fence. Replacing dirty filter socks and pit inserts. Also, it is wise to keep a simple log to show that you are complying with the local Authorities and Environmental Agencies. A five-minute inspection is way less expensive than the fines or stop-work order.
Uncontrolled Site Access
The site access measures are inadequate if mud being transported onto the road by trucks, utility vehicles and machinery.
Several construction sites don’t have an established entry to them or they just have a rock pad that has become covered by a layer of clay. Every vehicle leaving the site takes some soil away with it. That mud ends up in the gutter, in the stormwater pit, in the creek. It’s an easy issue for neighbours and the local council to see because it’s right out front on the street!
The best solution is to install a proper stabilized entrance. Use coarse aggregate or a shaker grid over a geotextile material with enough length for vehicle tires to turn a number of times before they leave the site. If possible, use one point of access to the site and resupply or replace the aggregate when it is clogged. If mud gets tracked onto the road, it must be removed on the day it gets tracked in. Washing mud into the gutter just moves the problem to an even more easily visible spot.
Talking about the construction site reminds me of the site security. Installing CCTV cameras is the best option for site security. Think about it.
Exposed Stockpiles
Stockpiles of soil, sand and gravel are a large source of sediment runoff. It is not unusual to see soil, sand and gravel stockpiles dumped right alongside the kerb, on footpaths or at the bottom of slopes.
A storm one time can create loose fill that washes down the street.
It all comes down to location stockpiles where it cannot get into the drains, gutters, water courses and roads.. Install a sediment fence down hill from your stock pile. If stock piles are to be left long term and there is rain forecasted they need to be covered with a tarp or geofabric. Where you cannot leave materials on site you should speak with your local authority about obtaining a permit but providing the correct protection is used..
Improper Water Flow Due to Drainage Failures
There are many sediment problems caused by too much water flowing across disturbed soils. If clean water from upstream passes across the site, it can become very cloudy as it picks up dirt and sediment.
Common drainage errors include:
- Not diverting downslope water around the site.
- When downpipes are not connected immediately after installation causing water from the roof to go into the bare earth.
- Unprotected stormwater pits located on-site
- Kerb inlets at the street front without any form of protection
The treatment is to channel clean water away from the work area through bunds or diversion drains. Connect down pipes to the stormwater network as early as possible after the roof has been installed, even if it is provisional. Ensure all stormwater pits are protected, on-site and at the street, with filter socks or geofabric, or with suitably installed inlet protection. The less water that travels over bare earth, the less sediment you will have to trap.
Failure to Prepare for Storms
Storms are not surprises, you can get the forecast on your handheld device. But that doesn’t mean that there aren’t construction sites that are harmed by storms days before it even happens.
The problem is that preparations for a storm are felt to be unnecessary at a time when it is not storming. As a result the preparations are overlooked. When a rain occurs on a Saturday night and there is no one on the site, then there is an enormous amount of cleaning to do on a Monday morning and difficult questions to answer.
The answer is: Stay on top of the forecast, especially when the storm season is. Before stopping work for the day when a heavy rain is predicted: empty full fences and pits from accumulated sediment; cover stockpiles; and close gates and access points. To prevent erosion from newly uncovered ground, apply mulch, mats, or temporary covers. And following the rain, do another walk-through inspection to see how well the precautions worked.
Neglect of Controls as Workloads Increase
The most aggravating challenge is the ignorance of sediment controls when the project gets busy. The controls are clean and everyone is doing the right thing during the beginning of the work when there is just a few people out there. Then we get busy and deadlines come up and we forget about erosion and sediment controls.
Fences might be dumped to permit moving tools, and the commitment to sediments control decreases with all the frequency of work.







